I've read it happening so many different ways.
So have you.

I've written it before.
You may have too.

It has to be one of the most cherished headcanons of a Caryler: when and how they will kiss for the first time. 

Now we've dedicated an entire challenge to more speculation on that most desired of moments: When Carol and Daryl finally LOCK LIPS.

You know when it happens in canon, Caryl shippers all over the globe will shatter glass with the sound of our screaming.

But, until then - we give you Nine Lives' FIRST KISS challenge.

(This is the first time we've had fan videos submitted and I'm so excited I have to list them first. LET THE WILD RUMPUS START!!)

THE FAN VIDEOS!!!

• The only one by Cherokee Rose (Na Bruma Leve)
• don't let me go -- carol + daryl by 1lilabut (lilabut)

 THE FAN FIC!!!

• I will pull you so close ('Til no space lies in between) by Na Bruma Leve
• What If? by Ab0810
• The Walls Between Us by mellovesall
• How to save a life by Saedhriel
• Genesis by silversundown
• Nothing Else Matters by Sira
• Fearless by Phantom
• Sleepless Nights by kaoscraze82
• She Wasn’t Mine by krissyg927
• dreams of a kiss by serpetinefire
• Of Course by Phantom
• Eight First Kisses and One Near Miss by viktories